Think of an employee who went above and beyond over the past year. Do they know how much their contributions mattered to your organization?
While you might recognize employees throughout the year, an annual Employee of the Year award celebrates someone whose performance and impact stood out the most over the past twelve months.
But for an Employee of the Year award to feel credible and meaningful, the recognition process has to be intentional. By establishing fair selection criteria, selecting an appropriate employee award, and presenting it thoughtfully, you set a standard for exceptional work in your organization.
This guide covers how to create a meaningful Employee of the Year award program, including selecting a recipient, creating a meaningful presentation moment, and incorporating the award into your broader employee recognition and engagement strategy.
Key Takeaways
- An Employee of the Year award is an annual recognition given to an employee whose performance, contributions, or impact stood out over the course of the year.
- Establishing clear eligibility guidelines and consistent evaluation criteria helps ensure a fair award selection process.
- An Employee of the Year award should be paired with a meaningful recognition message and moment so the recipient understands the significance of their achievement.
- By incorporating an Employee of the Year award as part of a broader recognition strategy, organizations can celebrate exceptional contributions while ensuring employees feel valued year-round.
Employee of the Year Overview:
- What Is an Employee of the Year Award?
- Employee of the Year Award Criteria
- How to Choose an Employee of the Year
- Employee of the Year Award Ideas
- How to Present an Employee Award Meaningfully
- How Employee of the Year Fits Into a Broader Recognition Strategy
- Make Employee Awards More Meaningful With Terryberry
- Employee of the Year Award FAQs
What Is an Employee of the Year Award?
An Employee of the Year award is an annual employee recognition given to someone whose performance, contributions, or impact stood out over the course of the year.
This type of award celebrates the qualities and achievements an organization prioritizes, such as:
- Outstanding job performance
- Leadership and initiative
- Exceptional customer service
- Teamwork and collaboration
- Innovation and problem-solving
- Demonstration of company values
Employee of the Year awards recognize a specific contribution or body of work, which makes them distinct from other types of awards, including:
- Employee of the month awards: An award that recognizes one employee for their outstanding contributions or performance during a particular month.
- Years-of-service awards: An award that celebrates an employee's tenure and career milestones rather than specific performance or achievements.
- Performance bonuses: A monetary reward for meeting specific goals or performance targets.
- Peer-to-peer recognition: A form of recognition where employees acknowledge their coworkers’ everyday contributions throughout the year.
Employee of the Year Award Criteria
The guidelines you establish for your Employee of the Year award will ensure a fair and consistent evaluation process. To help reviewers make an informed decision, create a formal rubric with criteria that reflect the purpose of the award.
Performance and Results
Your evaluation rubric should assess an employee's performance relative to their role. For example, a sales representative who exceeds their revenue target and a support team employee who achieves a high customer satisfaction score both showcase exceptional performance.
Make sure performance criteria are general enough to apply across different roles, while still assessing whether employees exceeded expectations and delivered meaningful results for the organization.
Impact Beyond Core Responsibilities
Criteria should also consider how employees went above and beyond the typical expectations of their role. Did the employee solve an important problem, help improve an existing process, or take initiative to support broader organizational goals?
Contributions like mentoring a coworker or working cross-functionally with another team on a strategic project can demonstrate an employee's impact outside their immediate department.
Demonstration of Company Values
Rather than including general descriptions like "great attitude" or "team player," outline specific examples of how employees can demonstrate company values in practice.
For example, if collaboration is a core value, you might include criteria that evaluate how effectively employees work with other teams toward shared goals or help colleagues overcome challenges.
Leadership and Collaboration
Employees at any level can demonstrate leadership and collaboration by taking initiative, mentoring colleagues, or guiding their teams through complex projects. Avoid defining leadership solely by job title or seniority, and develop criteria based on how employees demonstrate these qualities.
Consistency Over Time
Make sure your criteria account for an employee's contributions during the entire award period. Even if a major recent achievement stands out, it shouldn't outweigh a different employee's sustained performance and impact throughout the year.
How to Choose an Employee of the Year
A fair and consistent Employee of the Year selection process can build trust with employees. Regardless of your exact process, employees should always understand how their organization nominates and evaluates award candidates.
Define Eligibility Before Opening Nominations
Before opening nominations, establish eligibility guidelines for the award, including relevant tenure requirements and the specific time period you’ll evaluate.
Make sure your guidelines are inclusive of all employees, regardless of their role, location, or work environment, so everyone has a fair opportunity to be considered.
Determine How Employees Are Nominated
Decide whether senior leadership, managers, peers, or a combination of these groups will submit nominations. Allowing nominations from multiple sources offers different perspectives and a more complete picture of employees' contributions.
Ask nominators to go beyond general praise or personal opinion and provide specific examples of how an employee meets the award criteria. This helps reviewers make informed decisions based on meaningful evidence.
Evaluate Nominees Against the Same Criteria
Once nominations are collected, reviewers can use a scoring rubric or framework to evaluate each candidate against the established criteria for the award.
Involving multiple reviewers in the evaluation process also helps reduce individual bias so the final decision is based on a balanced assessment of each nominee.
Review the Process for Fairness
Before selecting a recipient, review whether factors unrelated to performance may have influenced the nominations or evaluations.
For example, deskless employees or remote employees may have fewer opportunities to interact with colleagues and upper leadership. If you find these differences may have influenced nominations or candidate evaluations, adjust the selection process as needed.
Employee of the Year Award Ideas
Once you select your Employee of the Year, the next step is to commemorate the achievement. The award should accompany the recognition in a meaningful way and reflect the significance of the recipient’s accomplishment. That can include options such as:
- Custom trophies and plaques
- Rings, pins, and custom jewelry
- Personalized award presentation kits
- Rewards and experiences
Custom Trophies and Plaques
Custom trophies, plaques, and acrylic awards are physical awards employees can display at work or at home as a lasting reminder of their achievement.
To make the recognition even more personal, you can engrave the award with the employee’s name, the year, and the title “Employee of the Year,” plus a brief description of the accomplishment.
Rings, Pins, and Custom Jewelry
Wearable symbolic awards like rings and pins offer employees a lasting reminder of their achievement beyond the Employee of the Year award ceremony.Custom recognition jewelry that incorporates your organization's logo, the award year, or other meaningful details can make the recognition feel even more meaningful and personal.
Personalized Award Presentation Kits
By pairing a physical Employee of the Year award with a personalized message of appreciation, you can emphasize to the recipient why their contributions stood out.
Consider creating anemployee award presentation kit that packages the award with a thoughtful message for a more memorable recognition moment.
Rewards and Experiences
You can also choose to pair a symbolic Employee of the Year award with an additional reward that suits the recipient's unique interests.
For example, you might offer a gift card to the employee's favorite restaurant or tickets to a concert or sporting event of their choice. While the symbolic award serves as a lasting reminder of the achievement, the additional reward gives the employee something personally valuable to enjoy.
How to Present an Employee Award Meaningfully
An Employee of the Year award can easily feel impersonal or transactional if it isn't accompanied by thoughtful recognition. Before you give the recipient their symbolic award, take time to plan how you'll recognize their achievement.
These best practices can help you create a meaningful, memorable recognition moment:
- Choose an appropriate presentation setting. Some recipients may enjoy a company-wide ceremony while others prefer recognition in a smaller team setting or privately. Consider the employee's comfort with public recognition before planning a large presentation.
- Involve a relevant team leader or manager. If you plan a public recognition moment, ask someone who was involved in the nomination process or familiar with the recipient’s work to present the award and share a few words.
- Personalize the recognition message. Whether you recognize the employee publicly or privately, make sure the recognition message acknowledges their specific achievements. Highlight the accomplishments or moments of exceptional performance that demonstrate how they met the award criteria.
- Connect their contributions to the organization.To reinforce the significance of their achievement, explain how the recipient's work contributed to their team, customers, or broader organizational goals and values.
How Employee of the Year Fits Into a Broader Recognition Strategy
An Employee of the Year award is a great way to celebrate exceptional contributions in your organization, but it shouldn’t be the only time that employees feel recognized for their hard work.
You can complement your Employee of the Year award with other ongoing forms of recognition, including:
- Manager-led recognition: Encourage managers to regularly acknowledge employees' hard work through personal messages, team meetings, or one-on-one conversations.
- Peer-to-peer recognition: Give employees opportunities to recognize their coworkers' efforts through social recognition programs that make appreciation part of everyday work.
- Milestone and service awards: Celebrate important career milestones, including work anniversaries and years of service.
- Achievement-based recognition: Recognize employees for completing high-impact projects, exceeding performance goals, or making meaningful contributions.
- Rewards and incentives: Pair recognition moments with rewards that reinforce positive behaviors or celebrate company values and specific accomplishments.
Also remember that employee recognition is just one facet of employee engagement. When you incorporate an Employee of the Year award and other recognition efforts into a broader employee engagement strategy, you can strengthen the impact of awards on workplace culture, employee retention, and performance.
Make Employee Awards More Meaningful With Terryberry
If you’re thinking of introducing an Employee of the Year award, remember that effective recognition is an ongoing effort. By celebrating employees through both annual awards and everyday recognition, you help them feel valued year-round.
With Terryberry, you can offer heritage-quality symbolic awards within a digital engagement program to seamlessly integrate employee recognition with your broader employee engagement strategy.
Create recognition moments employees will remember. Explore Employee Awards from Terryberry or contact Terryberry to discuss your employee engagement program.